2004-12-21 Damage at 10393 51st Court NE
12/21/2004 14:24 FAX
SEH ST. PAUL
Ial001/004
.'.
~
SEH FAX TRANSMITTAL
,
~lber-+b1~s
From: B.!/fa ber5
i:J Field OffIce:
Date:
S~H File No:
I
TQta/ Pages:
JZlzr /O'f
A -A-{...~l/ ~? 12.~
~
(IncWng cover sheet)
!'(URGI!NT '
Atin: tar ry Kru..-s P '.
l::oIOrg: -B~rtv;lle
FuNo: 7G3-Lff7- '3'210
Phone:
Atin:
CoIOrg:
Fax No:
Phone:
f1,'k-e c,t..(r~
'~-A.( ~ / HrJtL:.t':J t:"" {-f;,. ~ r-
c
7~ 3- t../97 - z ~ c:rI
Attn: ~ k Carr"'!!> G1"'"
CoIOrg: 71:11" tt7f ~th~
Fa No:
Phone:
Atin:
CoIOrg:
Fax No:
Phone:
Iff ~rf v,'/ {a$
Subject:
Remarks:
L~fk(" f(-eJ...-t R,'c.!: 11^1r1')~r~ arfd.rney re.1~('d./'/\ J
Wo~ k "'l. A~a. l.tA.
We..
o Sending original by mail
~Sending by FAX only
Cl Sending as reCluested
For your
o Information/Records 0 Review and comment 0 Approval
metion Cl Distribution 0 Revision and resubmittal
'i1 transml..ion was not received properly, pIN.I comecl the .Ind.r at the phone number above.
We request a response from ~u by:
docu....a7
1104
i
Short Elliott Hendrlokson Ino., as:!;;; Vect1aia Center DrlvlI! SI. Peul, MN 5511o-51ge
SEH Is an equal oppcrtunlty employer I www...hlnll,Com I 651 ,490,2~OO I BOO.325.~055 I 651.ol.S0.2150 lax
...
12/21/2004 14:25 FAX
~/21/J004 11:31 FAl 6127586701
. '
DIa-Zl-04 lDID_II 'r~11 I 8arn,tt
SEH ST. PAUL
SHORT ELLIOTT BENDRICHSO .. 5T PAUL
+ I T-444
. I. .
Ial002l004
IgJ 001
P.ODl/OCS F-4T6
M,S S & BARNETT
A 'Profcu1anl\l AnClclat1o.n
FACSIMILE TR,ANSMITT AL LETTER
4800 WlI11s FlI1'SO cent~
.0 south Sa'eiitl1Street
).{Inn.pos.. ~ 55402-412"
T*pbono 61:1..341.0300
Fac:Il1rlile 61U3U686
WWW.IIIoa.baf\S!tt.eom
I
Tbis ~ ""M'lS llf~ pog.. iIlclDdlDg lhls cover lettm'. I
DA'I'B: Doaemberll.2004 FuBNo.: 4S~98.2
To: Mr. Bob Moberll FROM: 4. E. Schl1IlUUlD
COMPANY: Short Blliott Hendrickson Inc. DmECT D~ No.: 612.347.0282
I
Origiual Will PoUow by Mail
FACStMlLE NUMBER.:
TSLBPHONE N'tJM]mR;
(6];2) 758-6701
(866) 83D-3388
coM1v.tBNTS:
'134""'1
,
I
*u you .n nol ,...... all _ or ... ~..,... -. ....-, Iv ~...._.. .,""" call 01.347."", T........ *
. CONFlDENrLUJTY~TICE: :
Th. deC2um,nr(1) tlCg., 1111 ,Jail fax cD1ftaln ao. az ~ "OPJ which f.r Z.ply p,ivillJg~d. Tlte tnfo1'1l'lQtion is
fnIotrbd on/JI ft>>' 1M ~rIri hrtDiMd ...,..,. ~.... "'" lho .,.I- ..../pi..." J'Oll .... haw;)' ..,{fI- /luJr "'ll'
dilClo.surB. GOJ'Ytng di;"l~t1Dn 0,. ths raking oj any _/~'" III 7'IJliana. on thl ccmtS7ftJ rJf the teler:opied ir(annatitm
erapt lu diflDI d,b".r")J rD tit. Intended reotpi.nt nrzmstl abow i, .I1'Zcdy pt'ohibirsd. 1/ you have received mil/ax in
~ .. no . fltlt lJ I. #rI2. " ,.,. Q 1M tP" Il'lal doclD1lsnt
12/21/2004 14:26 FAX
1,.2/21120111 11: 31 FAX 6127588701
i
IlId-Zl-D4 1DlD9u Frlllll'"Malll la.rnltt
SEH ST.PAUL
SHORT ELLIOTT BENDRI CKSO -+ ST PAUL
+
Ial003/004
IlJ 002
T-444 p,aDZ/DOi F-475
MOSS & BARNETT
A. PTotcllltGnal AssClclAtloD.
1D Wells F-raa Ctata'l'
90 SOI.Itli ~mll Street
MJrinaIpg\l.i, NN ""02-4119
Tclepl'lClull 6l:1.Jlr7.03DD
Fa~ 611.330.6686
www.mPsrb~-
'DIlJMM '" lIIIII.&lI\!l1
_ \I. D'lldJI'I
UDWI.IIl:lI. Wl~
'I/IIoUMIl'" If~
eB.W.IIA,Io\IIDI'lS".IIo G'LIIl'f:l. S~
llIlII.:'e~ UZ.M7.0281
~ Sch1l1l1MRtJ@moa-barnGIlOfn
1IDWAlIII,.1ILOlIf'"
ImRIIT \.1USlltc
tItOlofAS". .......
w.~= December 21. 2004
\MlnJ'~
WIIQIJlIL .. o;w
MJCI,Io\&J.WAJ,)l.IIr
..=:;. == JIU F.t4XAND FIRST CLASS JUll..
""'" if. lIIIIc:H
aM' C.II'lOII.
.:=.~ l~NALAND CONJI'IDJrN'l'LU
c:.tII a. ....
.....IcIW""*
JMI'lAo ..IftDoUlCl
'N. ClClloIA. lAY
lIAl'IC'tw, --
IAIUd LAZM\II
~ 11.......-
..uL'" :uau.
1IllIlI'I"~
J.flIICUIIo~
~o.~W'511
'MUtlllfot... ClIlM'"
.IANP~~ B.c: 10393 - 51 A Court NE, Albertville
....... 'lI1AU11n1
1h\YID"~
_~Jc:
1IIlI'1I1L...... Dc:m Mr. Moberg:
lMIIUI'IC:IfUIS
=:=..=
~u.~
1iIM'IIJV/' M. 1IIIl"fV,
_J.'ML1Y
'mIG1HI ~ GIoI1Iftl
YUWIlLI1iIIISlf
JIIIlW!II. UIlI
1ItIoL1A.1KID5
UWlB'Dtat. ~'r
.....u.. l&l!ll
KlCt::
JAN.\. Al.lMIIDItoCH
ClMMJ.~
AHnIDJlY oA,llOIItAMI>>
""" A, IC&IIM
'DIIIDJ 10. Yif/Ift
~1Io.a:m:r
JJIII'IllVIo ~
L'lIA. I.IWIJ1llL
QVQRIlII&
~ CUoSISlI,,"
Short B11iott B.Pdrlakson Inc.
AttentiOD: Mr. Bob Moberg
3S3S VadDais Center Drive
Suite 200
81. Paw.. MN 55110..5196
Our office repDSents RicbBrd andKrlsta ~ Homcl! '" Oe-velopment in regards 10
certain property loca.tcd at. 10393 - Slit CollEt NE, AlberMllc eprcpertY'). Sometime within 'the
last ten Clays. someone ftOD1 Short Elliott HeD.ddckson. Inc. (BBH) trespassed upon the Propo:tty
c..\1Sing ~igni!cant damage to tho front. side and back yards. No effort had been made to contact
om cllemt wi1h reprd to SEH'. appm:eat inteIlUOll. to re-gmde drainage easements. The first
notic:c our c1i=ts bad of any activity was when they discoVered the pte.enC6 of survey stakes on
their Property. Althoujh our clients were not living at the Property at the time~ 1here was a For
Sale sip in the ti:ont yard with a clem: indiCatlO11 of a part)' to contact. Yet, 110 DOUce was given
'bc'foTethe initlsl trespass UpgJ1 our client's Froperty. The OII1y WAY our cliel1'b;l round out about
}'OUI' i11.vol'vem.cnt was by IDA1ci1lg II number ofphonlS calls to the City of Albertville and tracldng
dOW%1 your ~ firm.
Our clients undeDtaoc11hat YOUf fum. ''needed'' to re--grac1e a portion of the 'back drai:n~S8
casement. Theta waa 110 indJcation a drai:naae problem ever existed "With respect to our clients'.
lot. or any other lot sft'ected by cb:ainage across cur dlmw' lot. Tb.e reason for the re--grading
rema.inS a:mylltet'Y. The area that appeared to be JDI1'ked out with survey stakes was quite
modest.
The pedins performed by SEB affected flll'mor= tban the area. marked by the sUtVCY stakes, far
n'J,Ote than oar clients were led to believe would be affected. and appeatS to be beyond the
drainage easem.en:t botmdaries, Tho side and. front yards not "Nilhw. th.c d:rainaie easem~D.t have
also been dsJne.ied. The dmlnap ~ have not beQ3. returned to their original $\lrl'ace
coJ1Clltion. SigM6.can1 fill appe81'S to have been Im10vcd frODl the backyal'd. Part of the
12/21/2004 14:28 FAX
., "J.~U/J!004 11:31 VAX 612'7586701
DIa-Zl-04 lD:aaam Proa-Yosl I Barnltt
SEH 5T. PAUL
SHORT ELLIO'l'I' RENDRICKSO .. 8T PAUL 1~~:I004
t ~-444 P.Q03/00a F-41&
Short Elliott H=drlcJaon Iue.
DeQember 21. 2004 .
Pag~ 2
MOSS & BARNETT
A 'PrO[u61Cl'CUl.l Assocll1ttvll
excavaUon appCLUS to be a ~ protected UDder state aDd federa1law. What wetland
de\h1f1!1l1tion existed for thi. aaa aud what p=:aits does sm bave for modifying wetlands?
Furtha:t 'What basis cli4 SSH have far treapessinl upon and daml'lgifl! our c;li.eflts' ya!l1 outside
the desipb=d drainase easG.eDt'1
Pralll1t1Y1t om clients" abiliqto.n the home for iu fait ~ value bas 'been sewrely
advemely a:ffectDd. As a coueqw:n~ ~ will ba.ve holdina costs for thB additional time it will
1IIke 10 -&.d. .. buyer wlD.iD.g1o accept tbc ~.Us pt~ daIrmgcd conditloD (since it
caDJlot be repIlired until !lptia&) with an a1Lpcc:tId.loo of sales pdoe.
It Is my nndersamdini.'l11at you soak to blame ycro:r bemnriot OD Edina Dev=lopment COtporation
for haviDI fi.Ued 10 satisfy ''wctJaud ~"'. Howevcrt it ~ 8EN that ttespassl!ld upm1 our