2007-04-16 Mundstock AffidavitST \ I L OF \ll\NfiSOI A
N1I ()I� bl?ZIGN
DIS M( T COUR V
I EN I H :CDi(IrA1- 1)(STRI(T
MSF TV'W Da�Nwatory judgwnt`Weacn of (oniraet
(our file No. Yh-('l 06-299¢
(fold Kcv Dc� clopmcnL Inc., a Cv'iinnesot„ au-n�yration.
Piamti;`f.
s.
(1!y bl Albcr[v�(Ir.
Dcfendant Thini Parp, I'I;thtlifl:
Shin F.Iiiutt 1lcndrick.,on. Inc --
Third Palm Defcntiant.
i C 1 iontc�- Inc.. a IviinneSota Cotporalion.
Plainti±t,
hdd Kcy IW!Iopmcwt lnc., a lliollesota rorporulon
Del andaa , 1 hird Pml-v Plai nlff.
S.
l QdAmd Agi eumg.
[ hud Party Dcicndattt.
(itv Of ;Aibet'trilic,
Octendant:"I hird Part- Pluintill;
a.
Shot; kHiott l lrndrickson- Inc.
ITiird I'mly Defendant.
('OWI Pilc Ao, A6-06. CV-4997
AFFIE V AT OF
mmkN 11t"�DS'I'OCK
OF MINNkso in
j
0( NFY ()I- 1(ji FF
131:iiu i%1umistock, being &A dul; s"arn upon oath amcs and idq,, , 110"S.
! run a Ploresslonal 11rLifle-n and plimcf1pal o! Saudi: PLU' at 10'k."()
\,:sh I I t A,."u I ue South. B I oo; I I i I -NJ i I I aeS I a s5 ul)
hinu, been estopa - only l ,. okcul a! Prepd! llu� sue la�ant IL
_actin d,aina�e,
uwhQ and envioll
QOMRA Aws Rw ccllnpk\ rakkunial. �oinlPiercfal and pubne plojecls, its Well
as ensince ring actin Aws, wmAysis or i 1111-okTical audits. grading Plons and other issues
relating to public and private Welopment since v)n,
4. 1 htuc 'cNic"cd the innial pivaHying s, a:i vCH a, leporis and
audits eXchangcd bet %kcial the pat Lc. in cKwuni & be man,a
5. A is Q ,lot NYOK ouwaL bask an my eqleicuci: it, a hrgIujccj,
that in ah rituatio 'us, HAMIlng PUting and dockopman OFMAnnial villdivni,mck INO -COOMEl
jni! ji-ea Mwil IcNos, includkin lint not laidled IA in %Mmr 'hwd KA ale set ill the
uITIOPliat'-, local OcClrunelltifl inutholir.- Mit:11 could iinciude On: cll%- couni,' Or vVa[ershc;d
dikil Icq, i'l the F cda.al Mallagcnicaa-Agency`.
6. '"' ul\ prollessirm"" opinion Lased (11 C\Nrivac-' as a PI'Orcssaonaj Enoill"L
in rcsAnual de% ck )"Ient' the
tuthollu% as to what to do all icnlltiol estal,hhillg the ninuallian structure Col proposed
Mclopincaus '\nically the local go%criling alult'lily .%,111 IAl [lie dCccioper %iha! the 100-veal
flood Iecris arc, or. it it stitch. has not 1,Cen itulclucnal or the
sarrmulchug "ca[CNIed, the loCZ11 '_'osiullilng authority %%IH !CjI the clu,"Clopo %Oalf to isc as the
\cino Ic"Cl.
7 In nly plofcssional "Xpelicnce, it 1; not only nc s u but essential, that this
al' I_'Xfdc of rci-ii(Initi docrinininuoll of file flood cici be Italolmed by [lie local
�Oco'uing, Mithoray. Such studiew and ananyes ne cyNanj\ evaluat., ji;ope;tjc� and �i,atej
Icaels
',�ond that of'alc� inchnldual ill opc!!v00%ncr In thlscuc, the %lawish"'d that %cjsapporently,
�n n_,
by 1301(on Niolk in 2t)06cicoalpa,<,tI in 'xcc.,s dic, Pliurle Run
,5 acics.
P;njniltul, indicidual piopert, owners, Ordc%ch0v to so any or wginnal IM
your J`O"d levels 'A'Ould lead to it scrious voicn, r-picccl-nedi- of flood I ...
licu could 'cut' to serious d""Palwks and cmw, "Twh could be, and are in my cNilchence,
iti%ca,a%(adcd he the "'o%elnnnew setting, .such Flood cick
in This e 'e, the i c% einpnie d Qrcua c a :,it(] /nInn Or Itn unec tir.)p.o. ubd.
dl ;neeitie 111,E allo v use of the wirw ohPen nonont IqHaH: , �_u,3lin,I it) esn;none In t I Iiuh wider
.: csatAW for the Prairie Run dc%viopntcra I ire -'hlvh aara elo zalolf i, the functional
it i%area( of [lie "oaduall� lu&n w ter level- hin is 10 tic dwityunhcd frimin dw hi hest krim n
surface ace %vater w%cF, Uch OI 1lh ch are d slinet terra ti )Ira" used In (he I)ecelopluent-Agivorient
and dcrivc,d hour the ordinance. I lie high �.tatcr ekeaataxl or nrrlinnry high stater revel For the
PrOinc RUI development was based upon the ring of ,unlacc;a aqulaw vc+gotaliwa and the
_inding pions tcLilive in the prckrn avr wad final plan rcFlccicd this
1n In m, experience, it tiac tlu Fnghneer had any p c.ofens or Koss with Ow (iuc or
perriancial nquotie O cmtmn 1- g -of as the coinizacd r; it ,�aiIt,.cl in; - Ll,l'IC RUIi
dctela>pracnt_ or if the (Vy wafed any adddicival in omylvon or +tuned dac l)cc-cloper to rise a
dlr eao m fi urc a (he cNialuded high wan I lecch then tilt ( its a Odd c lice Detelorwr knock
this yev Calk on in the process (risen the C 1t's complete silence rcgu I n_ the deNcloper's use
Of the Iinc of permanent aquatic. 1-09eIMIO . W os nwoe Ills high wnter elevation, Iol- the prairie
Run development. and given the (act that the ihseiopmcnt :A,treer,acnt and the relevant
'a(huaree spcelhod v 01110W rise Of Ids n:ednd to esl:.natc the high .varcr keel, the dotcloper
'vas ouificd lu use it and to rcly upon it in the ahsence cif info hellion of had l.rue_iom hrml (he
v uv to rile cuntrarv.
RvIallaei On rite AMC c P per L nun I aye .Ilic. ,culu on a, Inc cslrma es( hi h :voter
n rk is alcc ys stfl.ial to lec1" A the aPPI'UM e jokcniong authm1a.v.
In i � ploonsumal cspenwtu . ne e he nomad and csl,cctcd duties or rare
L nwo ncnis to acrid tilt prclimiaare and ruin 'I'll suhmissutns do,i--ncd he a dcveiohcr\
ctt�>ir,cer. including erachr,2.:(faiuurc anr! siurm sec�tr p?an.. (o dcicrn�inc .catcher Ihcrc arc unv
enginco-ing issues or dencienocs "it tl otic Myllyssionz and in dcel!nine moll r those
sun.uksion one in compliance .c,rih the p rtincnt ( it; ordinance and;o: (he Dexchtpnicni
\Niemen?. ,as !lie cast, puce he ht In', pastes ien,u spericnec if rile t itc kn�'1 el far, all,
corer is aLoul the plot ti;abmissR1 rs, or flo i.cs ,pad dercio nes of if .lw wralus ions fain to
Cor apI ith ('ny o die uiecs nl the Deeelc,pmct \gre"an n:. the ( i hugan ce: a.way s
"Inva ❑stages ihosc umeoms or dcilciowics to We ( it; ('outteil. "llo, At tun. either ,appluies
or to us the plat, or requires the ticivioper to rovise the plat ;ubniissions. hosed upon the
colrluaans or th • City LAYMcer in iris )a al s, on�al
I vs e.�l ea cn e, Liar C Ire I a�tne,a ,ahcvays
and acts this PIior to hirall plat ,appo of In t ac pu>t s:aon,ll c.epca uw ,the fadurc nfthc
LW , f Wriccr to conduct (his rodew of the plat enLrnicsa, is .a bleach cr fhc duty of cure and
professional standards in the proicssrun.
1 11, It is un professional opinion.nascd oll l;al cvporen c in: a Prolessional Lrgnwor
and the I'lloitardion pao%ided to rue. !hat the Prairie Ran greining Phu dated 5=14 04 con;plics
:c-th the Derclopmcnt :Agrcemcrt zuld I e gars. of ;Aibortc�illc's <uninQ and suLdicision
ondin ances In .ftcct in'_004 eriih lespeet to suuetu=.-c i m opening J"A'lliolu .
It 1, no lye fcssiolad opinion. d an ian tpra r nee as a 1 t otes,rcn d Fnsuaeer
anti d.c alhmaaatloll prop ided to nnc, tall all or Ih, ;arc tr sed ,truc'ura ciceaiaals ill tie acs« icutial
May' oft the Prairic Run gnading poll don 1 5 14 04 are acounwiv de I iyannal nod h rclvct to
Tc !me of pciamnem aquatic %wgcaoi,, ad arc conhisicrit b% Ili) I. he Do"Joplacrit
and the rcln ant Coy omomwe IN all,"k, use of this nellhad to canMlle e d1L,,h
hil-n tl,ied it 5 14 04 gmdkg ,lion aWpm% at h-% Ife ( ij�, cojljjcaj In hole 2004 andl lan,
ihw ill! ortlic rmpoSed stluclulc O%k opcudl� co%lul(ul, fol each orilic 52 lots %vcjL
int 9�0� or three J ')) feet above the lugh water Ins! of Q475 olcrvxul Ann Me liter orna pnnin-ew liquinic kcgoaifon 1001 In CSIM00c high "wr lo & Or the davelopnicni
15, Sf)ccaf-;cthe , with respect to the Prat is Rill aaddn, plan dainj �n -104 it is llf;
e�SiOna opinion hascd on, Ily expe;fie Ice ils ;I Piot-O—oral lalgancer and the injoallinion
ploojdod to nr. that there is no exasatifa' of proposed ailictine km opening cle\lItion III the
lcs�dcrujifl portion or the Praine Run duchTinctn that . jolaies ( j\ I)FAIllclMle's /,olding and
, t'all"Ision Oldlaimces in cfAct in 1 2004 basnl upon a high \i1an conation off)47.5 its dnhcd
horn [lie hoc ill, permanent aquanc wginuttion as usad to esilinato high tcatel icvcls kor the
dvelopmeni
"Vith n-spect in the iradragc adcaloRNI, Ita the 1llan-1c Run doelopnicill is OF
i4 04 Or as CantaRICNd- it is Jan, InOICsSlo.all onin all), hascd tni Im 2xperlfalec as n
Plol'ussionai Lingincer and the ill [of Inat loll inmided to Inc, thin there C Is no %filiaRion of [Ile
that the Post-dwAnpawnt HIM 'car wal !yak diielnjlf'e nth -off rate Should not
excn-'dl the pinlocioplacalt 100 ycal sioinn peak di,cha,,-,c jun-ofi ratc-
17, `,% kh respect in) [lie dlinflage calculations for the Prairie Ran (o\elopment as of
14 N of as consaucfa& it is nly pm,K,,d hacd on me c\Jj I., ace as i
mccl and [Ile alronnanon pm%RQI to Ine, dt,n there n, I() ,jo(lia.ul
or the
icqt"rcnicrn JQ dic post docloplaum (h.schaft-'e run. -of latc should not =exceed more Iran onc-
hai`oFihc tfischorg", illn-OH late.
11
i N. 1: to the &P irme cal cid, qM, hir We Pw 4 is R a n do c loMnen t as of
5 14 04 or to wy-Itanwic? it is an, pma,sIoaa, has i,3 rt� c\F)cj,cTice is a
Ploressional 1�11,ifl r and file alloluallion pawdled
in luo hiu thele 1: no violation of file
NqUircilicm that the surhlee and undayrouml drunage s,mcnis of the Fe\cj000)cru shonij Ile
dil0grIcd to imandc a xrnmrana solution for the adeqUille i"InMaj of a'- not! . ra! dr inna
UCCUMU!"I[cs Oil the propclr}, gc that
10. Specifically, wiih rwricct a) [fic
development as of 5 1404 or as constaned, it dlud"in' calculations fill [Ile Plaine Run
is vin favressanollill opinion, based On III,,
CxPchLawc as I Pl'ofossional Engineer wul the WOMMUnn pmw nod to 111%:". ?,11cluding nq MwInni
OF the devchorwr cnghwer Fkalund's dwifingc eqj.hu,,, watched , his sdeposition
Q (and Miached I(, fit arridnod as 1.xhjil)u \) as ExhWif
naliahos C !gulding each ilheatcluracra I. thill I Inhand properly neconated fol [lie standaid
Of file pranic Rial de clopfaejincluding dlaulagQ,
r,'rlchd FOads- till both the plc -docitillifteal diahlue": and the post-dewopinent
Cfidfna�c run-ol't rates, based upon 2. 10, and 100 oe'll onlisand that tho drainage nkas plopell,
nICS1,11CL I i to pie k Hey e a pananap Solution For the adnqume Iva,towal ran rimural druhhIge om , t
diet all!Isles oil the propelty, that the keafn nIllone, qui-ago and dischrarge syston in designed,
al"'ilichn" ill! storage norld Callahliahis tot rogn!"i For his purpow, pm% hod f post o,d,ra,,u
flin-OH low horn tile ilropctt that ([Ill not C\(:ec(j Toole Illal oN"-hall, of the pre
-
da,clOPUnfant discharge rum -off nrt. Un I plo"Ict! a lt)0 k"Pr sterns peak
thscharge n"wWwc froin the ploper!) that did no; cveccd the 100 va!r slonn
p,:Pk dacha! gc not -op rate
20, it is Uly nil fesslonal oplfuojlused oil Ink c,\palcjjce as n
a you storni would produce 5j I'loicssaolal 1-Ilincill,
Ind" Of min in 24 hours. and dmt Rich a swnu has a I
')it! 1:1ranee Of occurrmg in any gmfon you A oonn 111al produces 8 5 inches of rain In I
m)Uls could be akin I,) Pppr,xinja(cl, P 5_()()() ccal, and such a 1010 has a .02 pci-ccim
ChPlict: oroccUll ing in an., given �afj.
lo the extent the elu. cotinu (I! ne
beddisnicl pos<csscd ally allal}.SN,
!"ToRS Ol studies that indiolitid high k"JIa, Ice Is Hlal potIlliall" is a plopo,
WATnimm, in my c\perwace- this is ak.,aks ill\en �o the de%cloll. , C(d
et- Or CH'anctos
In"'oked in a partioral proict.n. III the a\fcat so'ch illrorruPtion .vas aknHabic and not gi%en to
the dexclopcir, 1 beho, e tills . Ms sallas nAwk, at hbraifofthe local 90%cmingaudwityand
oncrsIghi nwwriNmHT di -cal; U, om innihIcnis at im; sac,
21 in 1%, 1 ' Yews of clywrinicc an a pr<lt,iojjal engolo t 1 not ona"vale of' :If)\
ninnicIpPla..x has, aial-lhfacfllpol,cd I Utoottaillin or ow type
Coiscm0aled In the Plaine Rein Weblinnent lased Upon dato dociopol al'it.a. folal Phil
bluldcls Uld dc"e!opa, cl,, upon the ale', applo..a: Of' pait.s in
Pillod lunWW"Inn on a nornborann on all
apn]occd pint ";is MUM n0gillme implications & PH pan os hnoh,& ,,
of urc onll a;" no( drowd to, ad\._,:sc it Ill on oka I IU\c rnor,lelo�
"Ile! ope, O%el"
ol'nkailalle hoildinl! lads, and WAY polls OR lllt!i dolula taaislws I'll :1 site,
l4. fs fill, professional (,pillioll, I-asckl on fn\ kkipt-rialet, as a I'lo!"""smonal
and (lie inf6rillinion , nrovAwi cd to c ngwounrig HIC Incilk As ac Ps -the In Hills case. inciodirl not built Upon :is %+�k li� strUciares consijact-,ti on file Prairie hull dek Id )PI e g lot,
since 5 14 04
nurse
on! it zaly of file lo' Ned lzldog Phu's UP to and uwhdbg the i ! 16 05 ref Ned gradw,
Plan, that even in rebuon [0 the n—,% hil-dion konw.kil Cle%Ption CQ51 47 Feel ahm �� sea !C\ �,l that
the Cily atict-rilined of 20R6 requirmigivuefurns to be a minfli)(ruill) 1
Iiof�, is ill) UnIhnih lot %\11cic [lie jokkc"i Illoposed I )I' Q5 ;47 PbOk c sca level.
ami my one or we SI,\ oN-bUilf honles I opellaig is than 95." � f cet „boy 0 seal lc.s cl,
(14 am! RO bNow 99A7 i. . has a jO%% oPon"ll-' !lal is lt.s than 9515' (rooc ji,�aAccjj
2v is my pool cssiona! opinion. lased on nl% expenolce a.s a Plol'o'sPollPi and file l it to] TUal lot) pro% ided to file I e goldilly tile speciCie 4'IN at is,-Pnc in this olsa licindoll-, lots
nol )Udh Upon as "'Cil as sULIc'noos k:o!fsnUQncd ml Hic P1,11me Rall since �. 14.041 lures oill toe ")
PAL 001 eve, f file lo' [set! gladk Ann UP 10 and lWhAnng MC 1 I. lb 05 reds grading
in Wlion to We mov !M) Year ntwd Oka jqW) q e,a PI)oc sca 1�, k e I find Ill c
ok 2000. hatl k it(" as-bmh ill%. opera;Ig eievaijon�� Ili ankilill low opelling eklmlonw "Mac the imcsi proposed opening is Cs.s thPil Q.2,5 1 , Cel adlo,r feel la,ei.
I'R ) Ol 'R Af;t -N,\ I SA YI I I H
tlsc I I bcd ajld S . oo , on 11 to belorc mo:
u. A da of 200"